Federal Versus Private Loans for Graduate School: What You Give Up

With Grad PLUS closed to new borrowers, more graduate students will hold both kinds of loan: federal up to the limit, private above it. The two are different products with different rules. This guide is about what changes when part of your debt is private.

Side by side

Federal Direct Unsubsidized LoanPrivate loan
Who lendsThe U.S. Department of EducationA bank, credit union, state agency or other lender
Who can get oneEligible students enrolled at least half time; no credit checkThe lender decides, based on credit and income; many students need a cosigner
How muchUp to $20,500 or $50,000 a year, within the cost of attendanceThe lender sets its own maximum
Interest rateFixed for the life of the loan; the rate for new loans is set each year by a formula in federal lawFixed or variable, priced to your credit
Repayment plans tied to incomeYesNo federal plan applies; only what the contract offers
Public Service Loan ForgivenessCan qualifyDoes not qualify
If you die or become totally and permanently disabledThe loan can be discharged under federal rulesDepends on the contract

What you give up on the private part

  • Payments that follow your income. Federal loans come with repayment plans that set the payment from what you earn. The Department's own notice on the new law describes two new plans, the Repayment Assistance Plan and the Tiered Standard Repayment Plan. A private loan has the payment the contract sets.
  • Public Service Loan Forgiveness. People who work full time for a government or a qualifying nonprofit employer can have the balance of their Direct Loans forgiven after making the required number of qualifying payments. Private loans are not Direct Loans, so nothing you pay on them counts.
  • Protections written into law. Federal deferment, forbearance and discharge rules apply to every Direct Loan. For a private loan, what you get is whatever the promissory note says.

Where a private loan can look better

A borrower with strong credit, or a strong cosigner, may be offered a rate below the federal one. That can be a fair trade for someone who is sure they will not use income-based payments or public service forgiveness. It is a poor trade for someone headed into a long, low-paid training period or a public-sector career. Either way, the federal amount comes first: you cannot get the protections back by refinancing later, because refinancing a federal loan with a private lender turns it into a private loan.

Reading a private loan offer

  1. Find the actual rate and whether it is fixed or variable. For a variable rate, find the cap, if there is one.
  2. Find the fees, and whether interest that builds up during school is added to the balance when repayment starts.
  3. Check when payments begin, and whether they can pause during a residency, clerkship or other training.
  4. Check the cosigner release terms and what happens to the cosigner if you cannot pay.
  5. Check the death and disability terms.
  6. Compare several lenders on the same day. Rates change.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has plain-language material on shopping for student loans and takes complaints about lenders.

A caution about the numbers on this site

The debt figures on our program pages count federal loans only. For past graduates that was usually most of the picture, because Grad PLUS could cover the full cost. For students who start under the new limits, federal data will show less of the total, and the private part will not appear in it at all.

Sources

Related guides